1986–1991: How Did Shanghai Securities Counter Trading Actually Work?#
From Paper Stock Certificates, Manual Ledgers, to Trading Seats and the Birth of Securities IT#
Today, a securities transaction seems simple:
Investor opens account ↓ Securities account ↓ Online order ↓ Exchange matching ↓ Clearing ↓ RegistrationBut Shanghai’s securities market between 1986 and 1991 did not operate this way.
It went through a fundamental transition:
Enterprise-issued shares ↓ Paper stock circulation ↓ Brokerage counter trading ↓ Exchange-based centralized matching ↓ Electronic registrationThis period created the business concepts that later became the foundation of China’s securities IT systems:
Customer Account Order Trade Position Settlement Trading Seat
1. The 1986 Securities Counter Was Not a Trading System — It Was a Manual Securities Operating System#
On September 26, 1986, the Shanghai Trust and Investment Corporation of Industrial and Commercial Bank of China opened the Jing’an Securities Business Department.
Located on Nanjing West Road in Shanghai, the office was tiny — only a few dozen square meters.
It was not a stock exchange.
It was closer to:
Bank counter service
*
Securities registration office
*
Brokerage intermediary
```
There were no:
```
Trading servers
Databases
Matching engines
Online terminals
Market data feeds
```
The actual market infrastructure consisted of:
```
Clerks
Paper registers
Stock certificates
Stamps
Telephone calls
Filing cabinets
```
From a modern software perspective:
> The 1986 securities counter was a completely manual version of a securities core system.
---
# 2. Early Securities Markets Had Multiple Ledgers
A common misunderstanding is that early stock markets only had shareholder registers.
In reality, several different records existed.
These manual records later became the database modules of securities systems.
---
## 1. Shareholder Register
Purpose:
> Who owns the shares?
Example:
```
Investor:
Zhang San
Stock:
Feile Audio
Holding:
100 shares
```
Later database equivalent:
```
POSITION
HOLDING
```
---
## 2. Stock Certificate Register
Purpose:
> Is this physical certificate authentic?
Example:
```
Certificate No:
FLYX000123
Quantity:
100 shares
```
Later equivalent:
```
SECURITY_MASTER
CERTIFICATE_RECORD
```
---
## 3. Cash Ledger
Purpose:
> Has the buyer paid?
Example:
```
Investor:
Zhang San
Payment:
5,000 RMB
```
Later equivalent:
```
CASH_ACCOUNT
BALANCE
```
---
## 4. Transaction Ledger
Purpose:
> What transactions happened?
Example:
```
Date:
1988-05-20
Security:
Yanzhong Industrial
Buyer:
Zhang San
Seller:
Li Si
Price:
50 RMB
```
Later equivalent:
```
ORDER
TRADE
EXECUTION
```
---
# 3. Why Were Feile Audio and Yanzhong Industrial Historically Important?
Because they transformed ordinary citizens from passive savers into shareholders.
For the first time:
```
Citizens
↓
Purchase company shares
↓
Become shareholders
```
became possible.
---
For example, Feile Audio issued shares in 1984:
```
Total shares:
10,000
Face value:
50 RMB/share
Capital raised:
500,000 RMB
```
The issuance process was still very primitive.
Employees handled subscriptions directly at the company entrance.
This shows that the securities market was still based on:
```
Company
*
Issuing Agent
*
Manual Registration
```
---
# 4. The Complete Process of Buying Shares in 1986
Assume an investor wanted to buy 100 shares of Feile Audio.
---
## Step 1: Obtaining Market Information
Information sources included:
```
Brokerage bulletin boards
Newspapers
Company announcements
Friends and colleagues
Market rumors
```
There were no:
```
Online quotes
Internet
Mobile apps
Real-time market terminals
```
---
Market prices were local.
One brokerage office might show:
```
Buy:
50 RMB
```
while another location might show:
```
50.5 RMB
```
Price discovery was slow and fragmented.
---
# Step 2: Visiting the Securities Counter
A typical securities office contained:
```
Market bulletin board
↓
Information desk
↓
Order counter
↓
Cash counter
↓
Settlement counter
```
The investor provided:
```
Name
Identity documents
Shareholder information
Desired quantity
Price
```
---
# Step 3: The Clerk Recorded the Order
The clerk created:
```
Buy request record
```
This was the ancestor of:
```
ORDER
```
in modern databases.
But the implementation was:
```
Paper form
Ledger book
Pen
```
---
# Step 4: Finding a Seller
This is the biggest difference from today's market.
There was no central order book.
It was not:
```
Buy order
↓
Automatic matching
```
Instead:
```
Buyer
↓
Brokerage counter
↓
Find seller
```
---
The brokerage acted as:
```
Broker
*
Information center
*
Settlement office
```
---
# 5. Why 1986–1990 Was Not Yet a Trading Seat Market
Many people incorrectly project today's architecture backward:
```
Investor
↓
Broker
↓
Trading Seat
↓
Exchange
```
But this structure did not exist yet.
The more accurate model was:
```
Investor
↓
Securities Counter
↓
Manual Matching
↓
Transfer Registration
```
---
The brokerage counter itself performed many functions:
```
Trading
Registration
Settlement
Information Distribution
```
---
# 6. 1990: The Shanghai Stock Exchange Changed Everything
The Shanghai Stock Exchange officially opened on December 19, 1990.
This created the first major separation of roles.
Before:
```
Brokerage office organizes trading
```
After:
```
Exchange performs centralized matching
```
---
The market structure became:
## Investors
Responsible for:
```
Buying and selling decisions
```
---
## Brokers
Responsible for:
```
Customer management
Order collection
Cash management
```
---
## Exchange
Responsible for:
```
Trade matching
```
---
## Registration Organization
Responsible for:
```
Final ownership records
```
---
# 7. What Exactly Was a Trading Seat?
A trading seat was originally not a software interface.
It was:
> The physical location and membership privilege that allowed a securities firm to participate in exchange trading.
---
Early structure:
```
Brokerage firm
↓
Trading representative
↓
Exchange trading floor
↓
Assigned seat
↓
Order entry
```
---
The seat had two meanings:
## 1. Membership Right
Who is allowed to trade?
---
## 2. Access Channel
Through which route does the order enter the market?
---
Later:
Physical seat:
```
Trading floor position
```
became:
Logical seat:
```
Trading connection identifier
```
---
This eventually evolved into concepts such as:
```
Seat ID
Trading Unit
PBU
```
---
# 8. The Real Data Flow Around 1990–1991
After exchange trading began:
```
Investor
↓
Brokerage Counter
↓
Brokerage Trading Staff
↓
Trading Seat
↓
Shanghai Stock Exchange
↓
Execution Report
↓
Brokerage
↓
Investor
```
---
## Order Flow
```
Customer submits order
↓
Brokerage records request
↓
Order transmitted by telephone
↓
Trader enters exchange system
```
---
## Execution Flow
```
Exchange matches orders
↓
Creates trade record
↓
Returns execution
↓
Brokerage updates customer record
```
---
## Registration Flow
```
Trade
↓
Clearing
↓
Settlement
↓
Ownership update
```
---
# 9. The Origin of Modern Brokerage Software
The software modules of the 1990s were simply digital versions of these manual processes.
---
## Customer Management
Origin:
```
Investor registration ledger
```
Modern:
```
CUSTOMER
```
---
## Account Management
Origin:
```
Shareholder records
```
Modern:
```
ACCOUNT
```
---
## Order Management
Origin:
```
Paper order slips
```
Modern:
```
ORDER
```
---
## Trade Management
Origin:
```
Transaction registers
```
Modern:
```
TRADE
```
---
## Position Management
Origin:
```
Shareholder books
```
Modern:
```
POSITION
```
---
# 10. Why Did Centralized Brokerage Systems Become Necessary?
Because brokerage networks expanded.
If every branch operated independently:
```
Branch A
Independent system
Branch B
Independent system
Branch C
Independent system
```
head offices could not manage:
```
Customer data
Risk control
Settlement
Trading connections
```
---
The industry moved toward:
```
Branch Office
↓
Head Office Centralized Brokerage Platform
↓
Trading System
↓
Exchange
```
---
This transition directly created demand for:
```
Centralized Brokerage Systems
Transaction Middleware
Message Routing
Trading Platforms
```
---
Which later became the market for systems such as:
```
Jinzhen KCBP
Jinzhen KCXP
Hundsun AS
Hundsun AR
```
---
# 11. Historical Significance of 1986–1991
This period completed three fundamental transformations.
---
## Transformation One
Stocks changed from:
```
Internal enterprise certificates
```
to:
```
Publicly tradable securities
```
---
## Transformation Two
Trading changed from:
```
Manual counter matching
```
to:
```
Centralized exchange matching
```
---
## Transformation Three
Ownership changed from:
```
Paper records
```
to:
```
Electronic registration
```
---
# 12. From One Stock Certificate to Securities IT
The complete evolution:
```
Paper Stock Certificate
↓
Shareholder Register
↓
Brokerage Counter
↓
Trading Seat
↓
Stock Exchange
↓
Securities Account
↓
Clearing and Settlement
↓
Centralized Brokerage System
↓
Securities Trading Platform
```
---
A small securities office on Nanjing West Road in 1986 may have looked insignificant.
But historically, it contained the embryo of China's entire securities technology architecture.
Modern systems such as:
```
Customer systems
Account systems
Trading engines
Settlement platforms
Middleware
Centralized brokerage systems
```
can all trace their roots back to:
```
One ledger
One stock certificate
One counter
One clerk
One telephone
```
The history of securities IT is ultimately the history of transforming human-operated financial records into digital financial infrastructure.
```